Skip to content
KiweelyKiweelyKiweely

Five AIs, the same Workday tasks. Only Kiweely’s did the work for you.

ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini and Workday’s own agent gave you steps to follow; Kiweely Vine’s AI agent did the work in the tenant for you. Every answer was tried for real and scored on what worked.

We followed ChatGPT, Claude and Gemini’s Workday steps. Kiweely’s AI agent did it itself

On this page

The Workday Task Board

Each row is a real Workday task, given word for word to every lane and scored by checks run in the tenant afterwards. Each result opens its run record.

Task ChatGPT Claude Gemini Workday’s Agent Chat Kiweely Vine
TaskCalculated field ChatGPTPass: 229 steps by hand, 1 follow-up ClaudePass: 340 steps by hand, 1 follow-up GeminiPass: 257 steps by hand, 1 follow-up Workday’s Agent ChatFail: 240 steps by hand, 2 follow-ups Kiweely VinePass: did it itself, 0 steps by hand
TaskCustom report ChatGPTPartial: 295 steps by hand, 1 follow-up ClaudePartial: 212 steps by hand, 2 follow-ups GeminiPass: 277 steps by hand, 2 follow-ups Workday’s Agent ChatPartial: 178 steps by hand Kiweely VinePass: did it itself, 0 steps by hand
TaskEIB load ChatGPTFail: 230 steps by hand, past the two-follow-up limit ClaudeFail: 51 steps by hand, 2 follow-ups GeminiWaiting for Gemini’s quota to reset Workday’s Agent ChatFail: 26 steps by hand Kiweely VineRerun word for word, not scored yet
TaskBusiness process change ChatGPTPass: 57 steps by hand ClaudePass: 93 steps by hand, 2 follow-ups GeminiNot scored yet Workday’s Agent ChatFail Kiweely VineNot scored yet
TaskSecurity group ChatGPTPass: 64 steps by hand ClaudePass: 68 steps by hand, 1 follow-up GeminiWaiting for Gemini’s quota to reset Workday’s Agent ChatPass: 89 steps by hand, 2 follow-ups Kiweely VinePass: did it itself, 0 steps by hand
TaskWQL query ChatGPTPass ClaudePass: 2 follow-ups GeminiPass Workday’s Agent ChatFail: 3 steps by hand Kiweely VineNot scored yet
TaskExtend app ChatGPTNot run (test environment) ClaudeNot run (test environment) GeminiNot run (test environment) Workday’s Agent ChatFail: 6 steps by hand Kiweely VineNot run (test environment)
TaskOutbound integration ChatGPTFail: 262 steps by hand, 2 follow-ups ClaudePartial: 227 steps by hand, 2 follow-ups GeminiWaiting for Gemini’s quota to reset Workday’s Agent ChatFail: 52 steps by hand, 2 follow-ups Kiweely VinePass: did it itself, 0 steps by hand

Only what the checks scored is shown; a lane not scored yet says so, and a task joins the board once a lane is scored. Two checks prove nothing on this tenant’s data and are left out of every result: Task 1’s exact 1, 3 and 5-year anniversaries (no active worker has one on the check date) and Task 2’s Hire Date order (every row the checker sampled has the same hire date, so the order can’t be told apart).

Real Workday asks, done by Kiweely Vine

Each task as it was asked, done by Kiweely Vine in our Development tenant with sample data and checked there.

The task, as asked Where What Kiweely Vine did Film
The task, as asked“Is there a workaround to reverse the role assignment that was assigned via EIB to users in bulk? It was a role based security group assigned at the cost center level.” WhereAsked on r/workday What Kiweely Vine did43 minutes on the real clock from the request to the checked result, 7 of 7 checks passed. Vine recreated the bad load on five sample workers and five cost centers, and Workday refused all five rescinds, the fix the thread suggested. Vine then reversed it with an Assign Roles EIB using Assignees to Remove: all five cost centers went back to how they were, and no other role assignment changed. FilmWatch
The task, as asked“I’m working on a custom outbound FSA integration and trying to identify a Workday-delivered field that returns the coverage start date for the applicable benefit plan year, rather than the original coverage begin date or the most recent benefit event date.” WhereAsked on r/workday What Kiweely Vine did75 minutes on the real clock to the checked mid-year example, 8 of 9 checks passed. Vine tested the delivered field Later of Plan Year Begin or Coverage Begin on sample elections against the tenant’s plan years: a July 2025 joiner returns 1 January 2026, new 2026 elections return their real start, and a later benefit event doesn’t change it. Not tested: a 2027 election, since the tenant has no 2027 plan year. FilmWatch
The task, as asked“We have thousands of PDF records I need to import into the workers from our legacy system, and I have not been able to figure out the best way to import them. … I’ve tried taking the example orchestration for the Employee Photo import and customizing it, but I am completely stuck on building the APIs.” WhereAsked on r/workday What Kiweely Vine did41 minutes on the real clock from the request to the last worker checked. From a sample zip of 20 PDFs, Vine loaded 18 onto six workers through Workday’s Put Worker Document web service, and skipped the duplicate and a file for an Employee ID no worker has, with the reasons. Not shown: an SFTP site, and the Studio integration for the full export. FilmWatch
The task, as asked“I have a report where I’m trying to have one line per cost center, with various fields; however, I keep getting duplicates. I tried to filter them out, but that didn’t work. There’s got to be an aggregate function but it looks like Advanced Reports only has sort by. Would I need to pivot to a matrix report?” WhereAsked on r/workday What Kiweely Vine didUnder 30 minutes on the real clock from the request to the checked report, 3 of 3 checks passed. Vine explained the duplicates (a report on a workers data source gives one row per worker), then built an Advanced report that starts from cost centers, with a calculated field adding up each one’s annual base pay. Checked in Workday: 42 cost centers, each exactly once, and three headcounts matched a separate count. FilmWatch
The task, as asked“Has anyone ever created an Eval Calc Field with 6000+ conditions and 6000+ return values? I’m wondering how performance would be with this big of a calc field and if this is just not recommended at all? … I’m trying to map from Position ID to Legacy Position ID, which is needed for an integration.” WhereAsked on r/workday What Kiweely Vine did50 minutes on the real clock from the request to the checked report. Instead of the formula, Vine put a custom field on the Position object, built its EIB and a report, and loaded 12 sample positions: Workday took 10 and rejected 2, which Vine traced to their Job Management organization. The report matches the file 10 of 12, none wrong; the 2 are left open. Not shown: the full 6,000-row load and the integration reading the field. FilmWatch
The task, as asked“we had someone terminating today 10/23/2026, I had keyed this in like 2 weeks ago ahead of time but she was unable to get into Workday today on her last day? How do you set up the BP to where we can key term dates ahead of time but the worker still have access on their last day?” WhereAsked on r/workday What Kiweely Vine did37 minutes on the real clock from the request to the checked result, 4 of 4 checks passed. Vine found the Termination process’s Terminate User Account step had never been configured and gave it a one-day delay from the effective date. A sample termination keyed for 4 December went through approval with Terminate User Account still under Remaining Process, then was rescinded. Not shown: the last day itself, or a termination keyed for the same day. FilmWatch

Public Workday questions, done for real

Each question was asked in public; Kiweely Vine did it as a real task in our Development tenant with sample data, and we checked the result in Workday separately.

Alternatives to Workday Studio for integrations, without coding

Asked on Quora.

Asked of Kiweely Vine: a lab’s badge vendor needs new, moved and departing employees. Send the vendor only what changed since the last run, with no Studio and no code, and prove it.

What Vine did: chose Workday’s delivered Core Connector: Worker and configured it with no code: an integration system “Ridgeway Badge Changes”, employee eligibility and the vendor’s five fields. The first launch sent all 126 employees. Vine then moved a sample employee, Leah Grant, from Vancouver to Toronto through Workday’s own move process; the second launch sent one worker, a MODIFY with Toronto as the site. Leah was moved back afterwards. Vine explained when Studio would still fit: extra lookups, per-worker processing and complex error handling.

Checked in Workday: the integration system exists; both launches completed with 0 errors; the second file holds exactly one worker, Leah Grant, MODIFY, Toronto, not a full file; Leah is at Vancouver again.

Not shown: a leaver’s termination date, and contingent workers being left out.

Alternatives to Workday Extend

Asked on Quora.

Asked of Kiweely Vine: a travel company with no Extend licence wants employees to ask for home-office equipment with a cost and a reason, approved by their manager, all inside Workday.

What Vine did: chose Workday’s own Requests feature and said why. It built a “Home Office Equipment” request type with a questionnaire (item, estimated cost, reason) routed to the employee’s manager. A sample employee, Beth Liu, asked for a monitor costing 250; her manager, Logan McNeil, approved it, and the request was closed. Vine then set out what Requests can’t do that an Extend app could: no catalogue, no price lookup, no spending limit, no record of who holds what.

Checked in Workday: the request type exists and is active for employees; Beth Liu’s request shows “Successfully Completed”, with the request, the manager’s approval and the close in order.

Not shown: a manager sending a request back, and another employee being unable to see it.

What is a matrix report in Workday?

Asked on Quora.

Asked of Kiweely Vine: headcount with locations down the side and job families across the top, with totals, a click from any number to the people behind it, a “(No job family)” column, and the same counts for finance by API.

What Vine did: built the matrix report “Headcount by Location and Job Family” (205 active employees, 23 job-family columns, drill-down) on a chain of five calculated fields. It said plainly that a matrix report can’t be a web service, so finance gets a WQL query, which it ran and compared cell by cell. To prove the “(No job family)” column works, it removed one employee’s job family for a moment, saw them alone in that column with the total still 205, then rescinded the change.

Checked in Workday: our own WQL gives a total of 205 and matches the report cell for cell where sampled (San Francisco × RD-Management 3, San Francisco × Customer Service 7, HCM1119 Denver Office × Human Resources 7); the drill-down lists the three people behind the 3; nobody is left in “(No job family)”.

Not shown: sharing the report with HR, and a separate finance account (the query ran as the tenant admin).

How challenging is it to use Workday for reporting?

Asked on Quora.

Asked of Kiweely Vine: an insurer’s HRIS lead says Workday can’t do it in one report: one row per manager with their number of direct reports, how many were hired in the last 12 months, and which report has served longest, with their hire date.

What Vine did: built the custom report “Manager Team Overview” (23 manager rows) on a chain of 11 calculated fields: they gather each manager’s active direct reports, count hires since a rolling date 12 months back, and pick the longest-serving report, ties broken by name. Vine explained that chain as the hard part of Workday reporting.

Checked in Workday: our own WQL on Workday’s delivered manager field, not Vine’s fields, matches the report: Angela Bianchi has 5 reports, 2 hired in the last 12 months, longest-serving Brandon Harris (hired 1 January 2020); Steve Morgan has 4 reports, none recent, longest-serving Logan McNeil (hired 1 January 2015).

Not shown: the rolling 12-month window on a later day, and a manager whose teams are all empty.

Free resources for learning Workday integrations or EIBs

Asked on Quora.

Asked of Kiweely Vine: an office manager sent a messy spreadsheet of the Canadian team’s work phones. Load them with an inbound EIB, validate first, then load for real and report row by row. The file has seven good rows, one unknown employee ID and a duplicate whose “phone” is “call reception”.

What Vine did: built the inbound EIB “Canadian Work Phones” on Workday’s Change Work Contact Information web service and filled its template from the file. The first validate-only run rejected all seven numbers because of the dashes; Vine switched to digits only, validated cleanly, then ran the real load. It kept existing phones, skipped the unknown ID and the “call reception” row, and saved a row-by-row report.

Checked in Workday: our own WQL shows all seven numbers loaded exactly as in the file, Darcy Chan with one work phone and no “call reception”, and an employee who wasn’t in the file unchanged.

Not shown: two choices Vine made without asking (public visibility, automatic processing); it disclosed both afterwards.

What is Workday CF training? (calculated fields)

Asked on Quora.

Asked of Kiweely Vine: a hotel group wants each employee’s probation end date (90 days from the most recent hire, 180 for managers) and a status (“On probation”, “Probation ended”, or blank for anyone hired more than two years ago), in a report of last year’s hires.

What Vine did: built 17 calculated fields on Worker (constants, a manager yes/no, two Increment Date end dates, true/false tests and an Evaluate Expression status) feeding the report “Probation Review - Employees Hired in Last Year” (126 rows). The manager values first came out blank; Vine fixed them and ran the report again.

Checked in Workday: our own WQL, checked by hand: Carmen Cortes, a manager hired 1 January 2018, ends 30 June 2018 (180 days); Marianne Caron, hired 22 September 2025, ends 21 December 2025, “Probation ended”; Kate Moreno, hired 2 November 2026, ends 31 January 2027, “On probation”.

Custom reports in Workday with a query or SQL?

Asked on Quora.

Asked of Kiweely Vine: an analyst knows SQL, not Workday. Answer “which teams hired most in the last 12 months, and who leads them” with a Workday query, show the query and its live results, save the same thing as a custom report, and explain how WQL differs from SQL.

What Vine did: wrote and ran two WQL queries (hires in the last 12 months by supervisory organization, largest first, and the managers of those organizations), then built the custom report “Hiring Leaders” with the same ten organizations, managers and counts. It explained what carries over from SQL (select, filter, group, sort) and what doesn’t (data sources instead of tables, linked records instead of joins, security on every row). It first said sorting by a count wasn’t supported, then showed it working and corrected itself.

Checked in Workday: our own WQL gives the same ten organizations and counts, 126 hires in all, matching the report.

Is it possible to implement our own processes in Workday HCM?

Asked on Quora.

Asked of Kiweely Vine: a retailer wants one-time payments over 1,000 to also need the manager’s manager’s approval, with smaller ones unchanged. Test 250 and 1,500 on one sample employee, then reverse both.

What Vine did: added a “Manager’s Manager” approval step to the Request One-Time Payment business process, on the condition that the amount is over 1,000. Its first 1,500 test went straight through because the condition read an empty amount field; Vine found that from the test, corrected the condition and tested again. The 1,500 payment was then approved by the manager and waited on the manager’s manager; the 250 payment completed without that step. Every test payment was reversed, none sent to payroll.

Checked in Workday: the business process definition now has the extra approval step; no test payment stands; the routing of both payments shows on Workday’s own screens.

Not shown: exactly 1,000, and a payment in another currency.

How do other companies integrate with Workday?

Asked on Quora: a startup wants employee data from customers who use Workday.

Asked of Kiweely Vine: set up read-only access for a partner app to six fields for active employees (ID, name, work email, job title, location, manager) through its own integration account. Then prove that an outside program can read those fields over HTTPS and is refused pay.

What Vine did: built a custom report of the six fields and exposed it as a web service. It created a dedicated integration account as the only member of its own security group, with view-only access to the domains those fields need and no business-process access, and removed two grants that gave more than the partner needed. A small program then fetched the report as that account (205 employees, the six fields) and asked for pay as the same account. Workday answered “The task submitted is not authorized.” Vine finished by listing what a partner needs from each customer.

Checked in Workday: the report exists with exactly the six fields and is enabled as a web service; the security group exists; the program’s 205 rows and the pay refusal are recorded in the run.

Not shown: a partner reading many customers’ tenants, a report large enough to need paging, and the customer’s own approval steps for granting access.

Reports in Workday by several time periods or dimensions

Asked on Quora.

Asked of Kiweely Vine: a logistics company’s HR director wants headcount by location at the end of each of the last four quarters, side by side in one report, with totals and zeros for empty locations, and to know which report option fits and when the others would.

What Vine did: built the report “Quarterly Headcount by Location”: 13 locations down the side, 2025-Q4 to 2026-Q3 across the top, with totals and a drill-down to the employees behind each count. It fixed the page sizing when the quarters were clipped. It explained the choice: trending for counts at past dates, matrix for dimensions at one point in time, composite for combining measures or sources. A run over 2024’s quarter-ends showed empty locations kept as zeros.

Checked in Workday: our own WQL counts 79 employees at each of the four quarter-ends, matching the report’s totals; Chicago on 30 September 2026 has the same five people as the report’s drill-down.

Not shown: change between quarters: the sample company has the same 79 employees at every quarter-end, so the four columns match.

What kind of report writing does Workday help with?

Asked on Quora.

Asked of Kiweely Vine: a credit union’s HR team wants one report where they pick a month and see everyone whose work anniversary falls in it, with years completed, manager and location: active employees only, this year’s hires left out, and their BI tool pulling the same report directly.

What Vine did: built the advanced custom report “Monthly Work Anniversaries 2” on All Active Employees, with the month as a prompt and years completed from a calculated field. It shared the report with the HR Partner group, enabled it as a web service and pulled January as JSON: 70 entries, matched field by field with the report in Workday.

Checked in Workday: the report exists and is enabled as a web service; our own WQL finds 70 active employees hired in a January before 2026, matching the report’s 70 rows; November has one, Leah Grant (hired 23 November 2023), the report’s only November row, and the 126 employees hired in 2026 are left out as asked; Logan McNeil (hired 1 January 2015) shows 11 years and Beth Liu (hired 1 January 2018) 8.

Not shown: a member of HR Partner running the report, and a separate BI account (the pulls used the consultant’s own connection).

What is PECI integration in Workday?

Asked on Quora.

Asked of Kiweely Vine: a hospital whose US payroll runs at an outside provider wants PECI set up for one US pay group, covering hires, terminations, job, compensation and address changes; one launch with the output kept on the event; one worker’s output explained; and how PECI differs from a plain extract.

What Vine did: found that the existing US pay groups weren’t eligible, so it set up a test provider pay group, an external payroll company and the US country support PECI needs. It created the integration system “Payroll Provider Changes” from Workday’s Payroll Effective Change Interface template and launched it. The first output left out salary amounts; Vine corrected the setup and launched again. It then walked through one worker’s entry (a hire effective 9 November, entered 20 November, with job, address and annual salary) and explained what sets PECI apart: ordered, effective-dated changes with their entry dates, and only the sections that changed.

Checked in Workday: two launches of “Payroll Provider Changes”, both Completed with 0 errors, each with the provider’s XML output and Workday’s Data Changes and Diagnostic audits; the worker’s entry, salary included, is in the run’s screenshots.

Not shown: separate termination, job, pay and address changes, and a later file with only the next changes (three hires into the pay group were exercised).

What are the basics of Workday integration training?

Asked on Quora.

Asked of Kiweely Vine: a food company’s benefits broker wants a weekly CSV of active employees, no contingent workers, with a header row and set columns (Employee ID, Last Name, First Name, Hire Date as MM/DD/YYYY, Location, Work Email), sorted by Employee ID, built without code as an outbound EIB fed by a custom report, and launched once.

What Vine did: built the custom report “Benefits Broker Weekly Active Employees” on All Active Employees, an outbound EIB that attaches the file to the event, and a CSV layout for the broker’s exact headings and column order. The first file had the wrong headings and sort, so Vine corrected the layout and launched again. It explained how the report, the EIB and the layout fit together.

Checked in Workday: the report exists; all three launches completed with 0 errors, each with its CSV; the corrected file has 205 rows after the header, one for each of the tenant’s 205 active employees, with the broker’s headings and MM/DD/YYYY dates; three named contingent workers are absent, and employees with no work email stay in with that column empty.

Not shown: a weekly schedule and delivery to the broker’s own server (the file was kept on the event).

How it was run

Run from 19 November 2026 in one Workday Development tenant (a WCP Development Preview tenant with Workday’s own fictional sample company; no customer tenant, no real people’s data). Every contestant got the task word for word, as a consultant would paste it. ChatGPT (GPT-6.2 Astra), Claude (Opus 5.5) and Gemini (Gemini 4 Neon) ran in their makers’ own clients with web search and nothing else; they never saw the tenant. Their answers were applied in Workday exactly as written by an operator, an AI agent driving a browser through Workday’s own screens, who adds nothing of its own. When Workday refused a step, its message went back to the same chat, at most twice. Workday’s Agent Chat (the Self-Service Agent in the tenant’s top bar) got the prompt in the tenant itself; when it gave steps instead of doing the work, the same operator followed them. Agent Chat started a new conversation whenever a task page opened, so its follow-ups went into new conversations with the prompt sent again. Kiweely Vine, on the same Claude model as the Claude lane, did the work itself in the same tenant. Afterwards a checker who did not apply the answer ran each task’s pass checks in the tenant, written before any run and the same for everyone.

The full method, with every rule and every change made during the runs

Task by task

Calculated field

The request, as every contestant got it ({S} is each one’s own suffix):

In our Workday tenant I need a calculated field on Worker called “Service Band {S}” that we can use in custom reports. It should return one of these text values based on completed years of service up to today: “Under 1 year”, “1 to 3 years”, “3 to 5 years”, “5 years or more”. Use the worker’s Continuous Service Date, and if that is blank use their Hire Date. Exactly 1, 3 or 5 completed years belongs to the higher band (so a worker with exactly 3 completed years is “3 to 5 years”). Please give me what I need to build it.

(For Vine and WD the last sentence reads “Please build it in our Development tenant.” The same change applies to every task: chat lanes are asked for what they need to build it, Vine and WD are asked to do it.)

Pass checks, run in the tenant afterwards:

  1. A calculated field named “Service Band {S}” exists, saved, on the Worker business object, and is reportable (Workday exposes it to WQL on a worker data source).
  2. For every active employee in the tenant (205 on 19 Nov 2026), its value equals the band computed independently from the worker’s Continuous Service Date (Hire Date when blank) and the check date. Pass needs 100% agreement; the count of disagreements is recorded.
  3. Boundary: workers whose completed years are exactly 1, 3 or 5 on the check date (if any exist) are in the higher band. If none exist on the day, recorded as not run (no worker is altered to make one).

Note on the data: on 19 Nov 2026 every active employee in the tenant has a Continuous Service Date, so the Hire Date fallback is never exercised by the data. The checker reads each lane’s saved definition and records whether the fallback is there, but check 2 can only test the Continuous Service Date path.

  • ChatGPT: Pass, 1 follow-up. Steps a person had to take in Workday: 11 calculated fields (7, plus 4 text constants for the labels) built by hand; 229 clicks, key presses and fields filled. Checks: 1 pass, 2 pass, 3 not run. Full transcript
  • Claude: Pass, 1 follow-up. Steps a person had to take in Workday: 13 calculated fields built by hand; 340 clicks, key presses and fields filled. Checks: 1 pass, 2 pass, 3 not run. Full transcript
  • Gemini: Pass, 1 follow-up. Steps a person had to take in Workday: 7 calculated fields built by hand; 257 clicks, key presses and fields filled. Checks: 1 pass, 2 pass, 3 not run. Full transcript
  • Workday’s Agent Chat: Fail, 2 follow-ups. Steps a person had to take in Workday: 240 clicks, key presses and fields filled. Checks: 1 fail, 2 fail, 3 fail. Full transcript
  • Kiweely Vine: Pass. No one touched a Workday screen; Vine did every step itself (the tester approved two tenant actions). Checks: 1 pass, 2 pass, 3 not run. Full transcript

Custom report

The request, as every contestant got it ({S} is each one’s own suffix):

Please create a custom report in our Workday tenant called “Org Roster {S}”. When someone runs it, it should ask them to pick a supervisory organization and then list the active workers in that organization and all of its subordinate organizations. Columns: Worker, Employee ID, Supervisory Organization, Job Profile, Location, Hire Date, Manager. Sort it by Hire Date, earliest first. Our main test organization is “HCM1119 Outfitters”. Please give me what I need to build it.

Pass checks, run in the tenant afterwards:

  1. A saved custom report “Org Roster {S}” exists and runs with a supervisory organization prompt.
  2. Run for HCM1119 Outfitters: the set of workers equals the active workers in HCM1119 Outfitters and every organization below it (from WQL on the organization hierarchy), no more, no fewer.
  3. All seven columns are present with correct values for five workers sampled by the checker.
  4. Rows are in Hire Date order, earliest first.
  5. Run for a second organization (HCM1119 IT): the result changes to match that organization.
  • ChatGPT: Partial, 1 follow-up. Steps a person had to take in Workday: 295 clicks, key presses and fields filled. Checks: 1 pass, 2 fail, 3 fail, 4 not counted, 5 fail. Full transcript
  • Claude: Partial, 2 follow-ups. Steps a person had to take in Workday: 212 clicks, key presses and fields filled. Checks: 1 pass, 2 fail, 3 pass, 4 not counted, 5 pass. Full transcript
  • Gemini: Pass, 2 follow-ups. Steps a person had to take in Workday: 277 clicks, key presses and fields filled. Checks: 1 pass, 2 pass, 3 pass, 4 not counted, 5 pass. Full transcript
  • Workday’s Agent Chat: Partial. Steps a person had to take in Workday: 178 clicks, key presses and fields filled. Checks: 1 fail, 2 fail, 3 fail, 4 not counted, 5 fail. Full transcript
  • Kiweely Vine: Pass. No one touched a Workday screen; Vine did every step itself. Checks: 1 pass, 2 pass, 3 pass, 4 not counted, 5 pass. Full transcript

EIB load

The request, as every contestant got it ({S} is each one’s own suffix):

We need to load these new cost centers into our Workday tenant with an EIB, effective 1 January 2026. Each one should be active. Please give me what I need to do the load.

Cost Center Code Name
Cost Center Code{S}-4100 NameField Marketing {S}
Cost Center Code{S}-4110 NamePartner Marketing {S}
Cost Center Code{S}-4120 NameProduct Marketing {S}
Cost Center Code{S}-4200 NameCustomer Success {S}
Cost Center Code{S}-4210 NameRenewals {S}
Cost Center Code{S}-4300 NameData Platform {S}
Cost Center Code{S}-4310 NameSecurity Engineering {S}
Cost Center Code{S}-4320 NameDeveloper Tools {S}

Pass checks, run in the tenant afterwards:

  1. All eight cost centers exist in the tenant with exactly these codes and names.
  2. Each is active with effective date 1 January 2026.
  3. The load went through an EIB (an EIB integration event exists and completed), as asked.
  • ChatGPT: Fail, 3 follow-ups. Steps a person had to take in Workday: 230 clicks, key presses and fields filled. Checks: 1 pass, 2 pass, 3 pass. Scored by the method’s limit of two follow-ups: after the second follow-up’s answer (turn 3) the load could not be launched (the EIB did not appear in Launch / Schedule Integration and the security analysis came back empty), and nothing was loaded. The operator then sent a third follow-up by mistake; its answer (turn 4: a security group with Put on Create: Cost Center) made the load complete, and the checks above pass on what now exists. That success is recorded but not counted. Full transcript
  • Claude: Fail, 2 follow-ups. Steps a person had to take in Workday: 51 clicks, key presses and fields filled. Checks: 1 fail, 2 fail, 3 fail. Full transcript
  • Gemini: Waiting for Gemini’s quota to reset.
  • Workday’s Agent Chat: Fail. Steps a person had to take in Workday: 26 clicks, key presses and fields filled. Checks: 1 fail, 2 fail, 3 fail. Full transcript
  • Kiweely Vine: Rerun word for word, not scored yet.

Business process change

The request, as every contestant got it ({S} is each one’s own suffix):

In our Workday tenant, on the Change Job business process for our top-level company organization, add a To Do step for the HR Partner called “Confirm workspace move {S}” that comes after the manager’s approval. The business process must still work for Change Job events started after the change. Please give me what I need to make the change.

Pass checks, run in the tenant afterwards:

  1. The Change Job business process definition for the top-level company organization has a To Do step assigned to HR Partner with the To Do name “Confirm workspace move {S}”.
  2. The step comes after the manager’s approval step in the definition’s order.
  3. The definition saved without errors and is the active definition (Workday’s “View Business Process Definition”).
  4. A Change Job started by the checker for one sample worker after the change reaches the “Confirm workspace move {S}” To Do for the HR Partner.
  • ChatGPT: Pass, 0 follow-ups. Steps a person had to take in Workday: 57 clicks, key presses and fields filled. Checks: 1 pass, 2 pass, 3 pass, 4 not run. Full transcript
  • Claude: Pass, 2 follow-ups. Steps a person had to take in Workday: 93 clicks, key presses and fields filled. Checks: 1 pass, 2 pass, 3 pass, 4 pass. Full transcript
  • Gemini: Not scored yet.
  • Workday’s Agent Chat: Fail. Checks: 1 fail, 2 fail, 3 fail, 4 fail. Full transcript
  • Kiweely Vine: Not scored yet.

Security group

The request, as every contestant got it ({S} is each one’s own suffix):

In our Workday tenant, create a user-based security group called “Comp Auditors {S}” and add the user lmcneil (Logan McNeil) to it. The group should be able to view, but not change, worker compensation data: grant it View only on the domain “Worker Data: Compensation”. Make sure the change is actually in effect. Please give me what I need to make the change.

Pass checks, run in the tenant afterwards:

  1. A user-based security group “Comp Auditors {S}” exists with lmcneil as a member.
  2. The domain security policy for “Worker Data: Compensation” lists the group with View (Get) and not Modify (Put).
  3. The security policy change is activated (the group appears in the active policy, not only in a pending one).
  • ChatGPT: Pass, 0 follow-ups. Steps a person had to take in Workday: 64 clicks, key presses and fields filled. Checks: 1 pass, 2 pass, 3 pass. Full transcript
  • Claude: Pass, 1 follow-up. Steps a person had to take in Workday: 68 clicks, key presses and fields filled. Checks: 1 pass, 2 pass, 3 pass. Full transcript
  • Gemini: Waiting for Gemini’s quota to reset.
  • Workday’s Agent Chat: Pass, 2 follow-ups. Steps a person had to take in Workday: 89 clicks, key presses and fields filled. Checks: 1 pass, 2 pass, 3 pass. Full transcript
  • Kiweely Vine: Pass. No one touched a Workday screen; Vine did every step itself. Checks: 1 pass, 2 pass, 3 pass. Full transcript

WQL query

The request, as every contestant got it ({S} is each one’s own suffix):

Write me a WQL query I can run against our Workday tenant (through Workday’s WQL REST API) that returns, for each supervisory organization, the number of active employees hired on or after 1 January 2025, with the largest count first. Organizations with none can be left out.

(For Vine and WD: “…and run it in our Development tenant and give me the query and the result.”)

Pass checks, run in the tenant afterwards:

  1. The query, run exactly as written through Workday’s WQL REST API (/ccx/api/wql/v1/<tenant>/data), runs without error. If the answer gives no single runnable query, this fails.
  2. Its result equals the ground truth: per supervisory organization, the count of active employees with Hire Date on or after 2025-01-01, computed by the checker from the full worker list (every worker read, counted outside WQL).
  3. Sorted by count, largest first.
  • ChatGPT: Pass, 0 follow-ups. Checks: 1 pass, 2 pass, 3 pass. Full transcript
  • Claude: Pass, 2 follow-ups. Checks: 1 pass, 2 pass, 3 pass. Full transcript
  • Gemini: Pass, 0 follow-ups. Checks: 1 pass, 2 pass, 3 pass. Full transcript
  • Workday’s Agent Chat: Fail. Steps a person had to take in Workday: 3 clicks, key presses and fields filled. Checks: 1 fail, 2 fail, 3 fail. Full transcript
  • Kiweely Vine: Not scored yet.

Extend app

The request, as every contestant got it ({S} is each one’s own suffix):

Build a small Workday Extend app called “Team Tenure {S}” for our Development tenant: one page that a manager opens from Workday and that lists their direct reports with each person’s name, job profile and hire date, newest hire first. Deploy it to our Development tenant (never promote it beyond Development). Please give me what I need to build and deploy it.

Pass checks, run in the tenant afterwards:

  1. An Extend app “Team Tenure {S}” (or with that name as its title) is deployed to the Development tenant.
  2. Its page opens from inside the tenant for Logan McNeil without an error.
  3. It lists exactly Logan McNeil’s direct reports (from WQL on the worker’s manager), with name, job profile and hire date matching the tenant, newest hire first.
  • ChatGPT: Not run (test environment).
  • Claude: Not run (test environment).
  • Gemini: Not run (test environment).
  • Workday’s Agent Chat: Fail. Steps a person had to take in Workday: 6 clicks, key presses and fields filled. Checks: 1 fail, 2 fail, 3 fail. Full transcript
  • Kiweely Vine: Not run (test environment).

Outbound integration

The request, as every contestant got it ({S} is each one’s own suffix):

Set up an outbound integration in our Workday tenant called “Worker Contacts {S}” that produces a CSV file of the active workers in the supervisory organization “HCM1119 IT”, with columns Employee ID, Legal Name, Work Email, Manager, Hire Date. Then launch it once so we get the file. Please give me what I need to set it up.

Pass checks, run in the tenant afterwards:

  1. An integration system “Worker Contacts {S}” exists in the tenant.
  2. It was launched and the integration event completed without errors.
  3. The output file is CSV and has exactly the five columns.
  4. Its rows equal the active workers of HCM1119 IT (WQL), with Employee ID, Work Email, Manager and Hire Date matching for every row.
  • ChatGPT: Fail, 2 follow-ups. Steps a person had to take in Workday: 262 clicks, key presses and fields filled. Checks: 1 fail, 2 fail, 3 fail, 4 fail. Full transcript
  • Claude: Partial, 2 follow-ups. Steps a person had to take in Workday: 227 clicks, key presses and fields filled. Checks: 1 pass, 2 fail, 3 fail, 4 fail. Full transcript
  • Gemini: Waiting for Gemini’s quota to reset.
  • Workday’s Agent Chat: Fail, 2 follow-ups. Steps a person had to take in Workday: 52 clicks, key presses and fields filled. Checks: 1 fail, 2 fail, 3 fail, 4 fail. Full transcript
  • Kiweely Vine: Pass. No one touched a Workday screen; Vine did every step itself. Checks: 1 pass, 2 pass, 3 pass, 4 pass. Full transcript

What these results don’t show

  • A pass after follow-ups is still a pass: each chat’s answer was applied by an operator, so the time a person would spend clicking it in is not part of the score. Steps are counted from each lane’s recorded actions in Workday.
  • Gemini’s plan quota ran out during the runs; its paused lanes continue after the quota resets and are scored then.
  • A lane marked “Not run (test environment)” is one whose answer could not be applied for a reason outside the answer (Workday’s Developer Site would not let the operator’s browser in); it counts neither way.
  • One tenant, one run per lane. A different tenant or a second run can give a different result.

Send us a Workday task.

Kiweely Vine runs it for you in our own Development tenant, on sample data, never your client’s. We reply within 48 hours.

Try it on
your own Workday.

Kiweely Vine is free in your Workday personal developer tenant.