Buyers want a crossover point: credits vs another integrator. Workday does not publish that ROI table. You can still reason from meters.
Where credits often win
- Bounded Developer Agent drafting inside the 50,000 annual invocation allowance.
- Self-service skills at 1–5 credits per action that deflect repetitive tickets.
- Experiments in non-Production for most offers (with Deployment/Adoption exceptions respected).
Where credits lose
- Code-generation thrash at hundreds of invocations per ask after the allowance, at 2 credits each on the public Rate Card.
- Premium custom agents (3 credits/invocation) plus Advanced tool-call blocks without an operator.
- Recruiting/contracting skills priced in the hundreds of credits per document or requisition on the public card while volumes are high.
- Any scenario where you still need a senior human for security and Production—credits did not remove that line item.
Decision rule
If the alternative hire’s calendar would be spent typing first drafts, try credits with caps. If their calendar would be spent owning Production risk, hire (or embed an FDE-style owner) and still budget credits for the tools they supervise.